• About
  • ESA and School Choice FAQ
  • Stories
  • Take Action
  • Subscribe
Friday, May 30, 2025
OAK - Opportunity for All Kids
  • Login
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • ESA and School Choice FAQ
    • Staff
  • Articles
  • Charts
  • Testimonials
  • Videos & Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • ESA and School Choice FAQ
    • Staff
  • Articles
  • Charts
  • Testimonials
  • Videos & Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
OAK - Opportunity for All Kids
No Result
View All Result
Home Education in MN

Minnesota’s Public Schools Serve White Girls the Best

Annie Holmquist by Annie Holmquist
March 21, 2024
in Education in MN, Uncategorized
0
Minnesota’s Public Schools Serve White Girls the Best
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

In case you haven’t heard, March is Woman’s History Month, a time to celebrate women and girls and their accomplishments. It’s also a time to encourage them to break the glass ceilings of oppression they’re under.

But when it comes to the proficiency rates in Minnesota schools, I’m left scratching my head over this alleged female oppression. Why? Because data from the Minnesota Department of Education shows that the students the state’s public schools serve best are white females.

Consider the chart below. It shows Minnesota reading proficiency scores for male (blue) and female (violet) students across five racial demographics. At 62% proficiency, white girls clearly have the upper hand, while Black and Hispanic boys come in last.

“But reading is more of a female-oriented subject,” I can hear you say. “Of course girls would do better than the boys in that area!”

That’s true. Boys and girls are naturally different, and in general, girls tend to do better with reading, while boys tend to do better at math. This is not just a stereotype, either, as shown by Minnesota’s male and female math proficiency scores in the chart below:

After examining these numbers, here are a few observations:

  • In general, girls tend to do about five percentage points worse than boys in math, while boys tend to do about five percentage points worse than girls in reading.
  • White students lead the entire pack, with proficiency in reading and math measuring over 50% for both sexes.
  • Even though white girls are behind white boys in math (about 5 percentage points), the gender gap is greater between the two sexes in reading (7 percentage points), giving girls the upper hand. Hence, when it comes to looking at which demographic is best served by Minnesota’s public schools, it seems that white girls are the winner.

But this is not often the message we hear. As mentioned earlier, it’s often implied that girls need a boost, that girls are falling behind, and that girls are the oppressed sex. In reality, it’s the boys who are increasingly struggling in school.

Christina Hoff Sommers gives us a hint on why that is in her book, The War Against Boys:

[I]ncreasingly, in our schools and in our homes, everyday boyishness is seen as aberrational, toxic—a pathology in need of a cure. Boys today bear the burden of several powerful cultural trends: a therapeutic approach to education that valorizes feelings and denigrates competition and risk, zero-tolerance policies that punish normal antics of young males, and a gender equity movement that views masculinity as predatory. Natural male exuberance is no longer tolerated.

Perhaps you’ve read this far and agree that boys are getting shortchanged in Minnesota’s public schools. Sadly, that’s not the real story here.

The real story is that ALL students in Minnesota are getting shortchanged. It’s true, white girls are leading the pack, but their 62% proficiency in reading is nothing to brag about, nor is 57% in math (white males) … or 42% in reading (Asian males) … or 20% in math (Black and Hispanic females).

Unfortunately, those scores don’t promise to improve any time soon.

Recent conversations with elected officials indicate that the Minnesota Legislature has been working overtime to implement top-down mandates for education in our state, turning themselves into a statewide school board that cancels out local education decisions.

That means that teachers—already frustrated by regulations and school administrations hindering those in the classroom from responding to discipline problems and teaching in ways they know to be effective—will find themselves forced into a corner even more, spending time fulfilling the diktats of the powers-that-be rather than actually teaching students the basics of reading and math.

If we continue on our current trajectory, refusing to provide more education options for Minnesota’s kids while also tying teachers’ hands and preventing them from pursuing effective instruction methods, then we can only expect those girls—and their male and female counterparts in the other racial demographic groups—to continue their academic nosedives in the coming years.

—

Image Credit: Pxhere

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Tags: female proficiencymale proficiencyMN Legislaturewhite students
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
The Growth in School Administration Is a Major Reason Why We Need School Choice

The Growth in School Administration Is a Major Reason Why We Need School Choice

January 22, 2024
ESA and School Choice FAQ

ESA and School Choice FAQ

October 4, 2023
Parents Are Increasingly Concerned About School Violence … and This Video Explains Why

Parents Are Increasingly Concerned About School Violence … and This Video Explains Why

September 28, 2023
The Best School Districts in Minnesota … and How Each Performs Academically

The Best School Districts in Minnesota … and How Each Performs Academically

June 21, 2024

A Victory for Kids!

0

FOX9: Hope Academy in North Minneapolis: Private school lets parents decide between in-person or distance learning

0

Catholic school in North St. Paul has built up a waiting list for enrollment with families who don’t want to start the year in hybrid or distance learning

0
ESA and School Choice FAQ

ESA and School Choice FAQ

0
People Greatly Underestimate Public School Spending

People Greatly Underestimate Public School Spending

May 28, 2025
How Mississippi Schools are Better Than Minnesota’s

How Mississippi Schools are Better Than Minnesota’s

May 14, 2025
Nearly 3/4 of Public School Teachers Support ESAs

Nearly 3/4 of Public School Teachers Support ESAs

May 5, 2025
A Tale of Two Eras: Minnesota Math Over the Years

A Tale of Two Eras: Minnesota Math Over the Years

April 22, 2025
OAK - Opportunity for All Kids

© 2023
Opportunity for All Kids

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • About
  • ESA & School Choice FAQs
  • $7k for Kids
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • ESA and School Choice FAQ
    • Staff
  • Articles
  • Charts
  • Testimonials
  • Videos & Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Subscribe

© 2023
Opportunity for All Kids